Best practices for managing inactive users

Alex Dunne · 2024-02-28T14:18:25+00:00

There was an error rendering this rich post.

Hi everyone!

I'm doing some research and looking for best practices on how other communities manage inactive users.

Our Community is a closed B2B SAAS Community and some of the metrics we track are:

Overall Community numbers
% of passive users (what we define as users who log in and "lurk" but don't actively post or comment)
% of active users (what we define as users who like, post, comment etc.)

I recently ran a report of anyone who has been inactive for more than 6 months and it's a bigger number than I'd like. We haven't put in place a policy around removing users yet so I'm thinking the best course of action would be to:

Run a "we miss you" campaign and remove anyone who we get a bounce back email from
Run the report again a period of time later (1 month? 2?) and if those people still haven't logged back in, remove them (unfortunately our total numbers would go down but our active and passive % will go way up…).

I wanted to get advice from what others are doing before I put anything in place - how do you deal with inactive users? Do you utilize any integrations to help manage this? Any and all advice is appreciated, thank you!

Find more posts tagged with

User Management

Comments

Kirstie Macfarlane

Hi @Alex Dunne - thanks for your question!

Firstly I would like to clarify that for many communities, passive users are not seen as a completely negative thing (or at least not so far as to remove them). For example, if you run a support community, and a lot of your users simply log in and search their questions, every answer they find means one less support ticket being opened!

However I completely understand that an active user is much more valuable.

You mentioned running a "We miss you campaign" to see if any emails are inactive. Do you regularly send out emails to encourage users back into your community? Even just something like a "Community Corner" in a regular outreach you have?

We like to run regular email campaigns (I'm sure you've received some!) via Catalyst, and we're also leveraging our new Email Digest feature to send some of the more popular weekly posts to our users in order to encourage them back into the community.

Looking forward to what others have to share!

Here are some additional posts you may find interesting:

#TipTuesday - Fueling User-Generated Content in Your Community

We're spilling our secrets for reviving online communities and driving engagement [ recording ]

Seeking ideas for a catchy day-of-the-week outreach program

Alex Dunne

Thanks @Kirstie Macfarlane , all of this is great and definitely something for me to delve further into. The reason we're keen on removing inactive users (we define it slightly differently - we're happy with our passive users but don't want a huge number of fully inactive users) is that we have a lot of proprietorial material in there and we like to keep that locked down so we're trying to find the best way to figure out how and when to remove those people. Looking forward to seeing what other people are doing!

LiselotteP

Hi!

I do two things:

User management: anyone that has not logged in for +1 year goes into an 'Alumni' role. This is means they are no longer what we consider an active part of our user base. They can still view content, but it gives me clean numbers in the dashboard.
We miss you emails: every 2 weeks, I'll PM users that have not logged in for the past x weeks with a we miss you email template, which includes 3 top discussions from the last month that they've missed.

Hope that helps!

Liselotte

Alex Dunne

Thanks @LiselotteP ! This is super helpful. We were also considering moving users into an Alumnae role rather than outright deleting to avoid the issue of the [deleted user] showing up on posts because it looks awful.

LiselotteP

@s_andrews, tagging you since I saw you just talked about this on another thread!

Edit: apologies, saw that you linked to this already!

s_andrews

Thanks @LiselotteP

I'll repost and some of my blue-sky thoughts 😀

One of the items that was on our list of things we'd like is to delete users after x years of inactivity (On a 20yr old forum with 2m registered that's massive!).

But I hadn't considered what our forum would look like with so many Deleted_user's everywhere.

So we might go back to our data people with the 'Alumnae' idea - keeping the username.

Problem is that one of the reasons a company might want to do this in the first place is for good data-retention practice - to remove email addresses you don't need to hold.

One thought I had which would be a bit of an ask from HL, but maybe a smaller community could do manually if they REALLY want to make sure they're not holding data they don't have to - manually keep a hash of the email instead of the real email address.

For example. If you put example@example.com into a SHA-256 generator you get:

31c5543c1734d25c7206f5fd591525d0295bec6fe84ff82f946a34fe970a1e66

If you stored that in some way and deleted the email address, you can never figure out what the original email address was from the code, but if someone comes along later wanting their account back emailing from example@example.com, you can run it through a generator and see if code matches.

Quick Links

Upcoming Events

Spring Product Roadmap Webinar 2025 🌱 🌷 🐣
Join us for an exclusive webinar where we’ll showcase our recent feature updates, as well as unveil some of the exciting items coming soon on our product roadmap! Discover how our upcoming features and enhancements will empower your community, improve engagement, and streamline your workflows. This is your chance to gain…
How the Rules of SEO Are Being Rewritten in 2025
Generative Engine Optimization? AIOs? The end of search as we know it? 2025 promises to be a long, strange year for SEO. If you’re wondering how to survive it, you’re not alone. Learn more about the key trends driving change in search, which ones teams will need to adapt to, and which ones are just scary acronyms you’re…
HLV Connect: Open Session
⭐️ Got something cool to share? Have a victory in your community and want to show off your accomplishments with fellow community builders? 🙋 Got questions? Bring your community, tactical and random questions and get answers from peers and Vanilla experts! 🗓 Join me and @paddykelly, and a group of your peers for our next…