-
1. You’re Reporting the Wrong Community Metrics
You’re doing the work. You’re growing engagement. You’re increasing activity. You’re tracking your metrics. When leadership asks, “What’s the ROI of the community?” and it’s harder to answer than it should be, that’s the moment where community loses influence. It’s not that the value isn’t there, but we lose influence when…
-
2. You’re proving effort, not impact
Mistake #1: You’re reporting activity, not impact Let’s start with the most common mistake: Reporting activity without tying it to business outcomes. This happens for a reason: activity is the easiest data to access. It’s what dashboards show, and it’s what many teams are asked to report early on. While activity data…
-
3. Stop trying to prove ROI perfectly
Mistake #2: Trying to prove causation Proving causation is where many community leaders get stuck, because without perfect data, it can feel risky to say “Community is driving this outcome.” The truth is, you don’t need perfect causation to tell a strong ROI story. What you need is responsible, directional insight. What…
-
4. Your report isn’t wrong, it’s just not relevant
Mistake #3: You're sending the same report to everyone If you’ve ever sent a report you felt good about and got “hey, this is great”, and the crickets…this is usually why. It’s not that your data is wrong. It’s that it’s not relevant to the person reading it. Your CFO, Head of Product, and Support Lead are all measuring…
-
5. More data is hurting your story
Mistake #4: Too much data, not enough clarity This usually comes from a good place. You want to show the full value of your work. You don’t want anything to be overlooked. So you include everything. Dashboards. Charts. Metrics. Unfortunately, this creates a different problem: It becomes harder to see what actually matters.…